8 Best Hypoallergenic Mascaras of 2022

From a brand renowned for its sensitive skin-friendly formulas, Almay’s hypoallergenic, ophthalmologist-tested, fragrance-free thickening mascara is a Walmart best-seller. “It makes my eyelashes look thick and full, and it’s hypoallergenic so it’s gentle,” a reviewer reported. “I won’t buy any other brands from now on.”

Made for easy removal with water, this hypoallergenic and contact lens-safe Maybelline mascara is top-rated at Ulta for delivering a subtly defined effect. “I wear contacts and this does not bother them at all,” a reviewer noted. “It gives a soft, natural look, which I love for every day, with no flaking or clumping.”